Should a refrigerator have water and ice in the door?
Only if you will use it every day. Ice makers and door dispensers are the two most reported refrigerator problems; internal water plus a freezer ice maker gives most of the convenience with far less risk.
Consumer Reports estimates 30% of refrigerators with ice makers have a problem by the end of the fifth year, and lists ice makers and dispensers as the two most commonly reported problems.
A Boston-area retailer’s service data and a Mr. Appliance franchise owner both name door ice and water as the most common service call. Repairs run $350–$500 for an ice maker and $170–$500 for a dispenser.
Confidence: multi-source · Based on 4 cited sources.
Sources
- Most and Least Reliable Refrigerator Brands · Consumer Reports
- Fridge frustration: the quest of finding a reliable refrigerator · Boston 25 News
- Most Reliable Counter-Depth French Door Refrigerators for 2026 · Yale Appliance
- How Much Does It Cost to Repair a Refrigerator? · Fixr
Read the complete guide
Best Refrigerator for the Money: What Type to Buy and How Much to SpendBy Purchasd Research. We used Consumer Reports’ public reliability page and secondary reporting of its paywalled rankings for survey evidence; one retailer’s published first-year service data; an extended-warranty company’s style failure comparison; repair-cost and warranty guides; ENERGY STAR for efficiency; a dated sale-price roundup for prices; and owner evidence from twenty-four Reddit threads (about 500 comments), including eight on Sub-Zero and column refrigerators, a Reddit aggregation (231 comments, 18 subreddits), two owner forums and three deal threads. Owner evidence was used to find recurring complaints, never to estimate failure rates. No specific model was tested or picked. Purchasd received no manufacturer payment, review units or affiliate consideration for this research. Several sources sell appliances, parts, extended warranties or financing, and each is labeled by bias. Purchasd has not tested any of these refrigerators.